Neil Cicierega – vocals, keyboards, guitar, programming, percussion, songwriting, production (2003–present)
Alora Lanzillotta – bass guitar, vocals (2004–2012)
Charles "Chooch" Sergio – guitar (2006–2012)
Anthony Wry – drums (2007–2008), guitar, vocals (2012)
Dave Kitsberg – guitar, vocals (2008–2012)
Greg Lanzillotta – drums (2009–2012)